Depends, some people play with funny gag type gifts and others play with normal gifts. There’s usually a budget. It’s also helpful if you know the type of people you’ll be playing with, so you can choose a gift that will actually be funny or useful to that crowd. (Depending on the style you’re playing)
Fun snacks from Trader Joe’s! Also could do a little Lego kit, people are always surprised and happy to get them :)
We always did weird funny gifts at my work. One year everyone randomly wanted the cactus shaped candle and fought over it. There was also a seat cushion that got passed around from year to year. Oh and I got a squatty potty one time 😂
I remember one year my ex found a sodastream for $25 on black Friday and that was a hit. If it isn't joke gifts I'd bring something you'd enjoy getting.
Did they say a budget? Gift cards in mugs are always good. AMC gift card. Starbucks. Etc. maybe a throw blanket. Wine glass sets. I’ve seen people do a lot of things