Thoughts on ASQ questionnaire?

I find the whole questionnaire process so stressful. Call me dubious, but I find the whole questionnaire very daunting for: • New parents who are just on a learning curve; their child isn't the only one trying to figure things out. The parents are too. • Parents of children with learning difficulties. • Parents who have underlying mental health disorders, including in the postpartum period, such as anxiety disorder and/or OCD. Honestly? If I could choose to, I would scrap it. Yes, I understand it can be an assessment tool of a child's development, but I think these can be mentally damaging for both the child and the parent(s). Like, imagine someone saying to you that your child has a developmental delay. You might or might not think, "have I been doing something wrong?", “are they behind because of something I have or haven’t done?”. This is not a post to bait people, but I think these can do more harm to a child and parent than good, and that really if there are concerns about a child's development, the parents should be able to reach out to their health care provider themselves for early intervention, rather than a questionnaire deciding that for them. Each child develops at their own pace. I think they should all be given a chance to learn, don't be so critical on the child with a questionnaire "cut-off", and be open-minded about considering intervention if you think that your child needs it. That is all ❤️ (Picture grabbed for context).
Like
Share Mobile
Share
  • Share

Show your support

I did the 10 month one a few months ago and one of the questions was : Does your child try to get a raisin out of a bottle? In which world is this a regular scenario.

I think the point is to not make people anxious or to blame anyone. Most parents would want to know if there are any delays because early intervention is key in most instances. So although this can be traumatic and sometimes inaccurate, I bet it does more good than bad at catching delays so that the child can get help they need.

@Nichole I don’t think it’s meant to be a regular scenario, I think you are supposed to give that scenario/test for your child as you read the questions, before you go to the appointment. We also had this bottle question. Another one was, “does your child understand that the toy still exists after you cover it with a blanket?”. I didn’t know the answer, so I did with my kid. All of these are supposed to test key developmental and cognitive abilities for their age.

Honestly I take things like this with a laughable approach my son is currently under cdc and “scored” quite low on one of these but it made him start getting through the system a lot faster than had we probably not had one . I never even tested him on some of them I just knew him and knew hed have no interest in doing it . If anything I think they’re quite fun in away but that’s me personally obviously x

Read more on Peanut
Trending in our community